Seasonal Flavors

Peace Pies Shipped directly to you!

The Pumpkin Patch 6-Pack

The Pumpkin Patch 6-Pack

Get ready to take a stroll through the tastiest pumpkin patch

2x Double Pumpkin
2x Pumpkin Pie
2x Pumpkin Latte

$90.00
$90.00
Harvest Haven 12-Pack

Harvest Haven 12-Pack

Seasonal treats to get you in the Fall mood

2x Pumpkin Pie
2x Double Pumpkin
2x Pumpkin Latte
2x Pecan Pie
2x Caramel Apple
2x Cinnamon Bun

$175.00
$175.00
Harvest Haven 24-Pack

Harvest Haven 24-Pack

A double-helping of Fall treats

4x Pumpkin Pie
4x Double Pumpkin
4x Pumpkin Latte
4x Pecan Pie
4x Caramel Apple
2x Cinnamon Bun
2x Caramel Coffee Toffee

$225.00
$225.00

Get your peace pie dozen

THE PERFECT ADDITION TO YOUR FREEZER!

12-pack of peace pies

Peace Pie Classics 12-Pack

The Peace Pies That Started It All

Caramel Brownie
Pecan Pie
Cookies N' Cream
Strawberry Shortcake
Banana Cream
Coconut Cream
Boston Cream
Key Lime Pie
Caramel Apple
Molten Chocolate
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate Mint

$165.00
$165.00
Caramel Heaven's 12-Pack

Caramel Heaven's 12-Pack

Fall in love with our velvety house-made caramel

3x Salted Caramel Brownie
3x Caramel Coffee Toffee
3x Candy Bar
3x Slated Caramel Apple

$165.00
$165.00
Peanut Butter Lovers 12-Pack

Peanut Butter Lovers 12-Pack

Calling all peanut butter lovers

2x Peanut Butter Cup
2x Peanut Butter Brownie
2x Peanut Butter Cookie Dough
2x Candy Bar
Peanut Butter Pretzel
The Elvis
Peanut Butter Blondie
PB&J

$165.00
$165.00
Chocolate Obsession 12-Pack

Chocolate Obsession 12-Pack

Chocolate Chocolate Chocolate!!!

Caramel Brownie
Cookie Dough
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
S'mores
Candy Bar
The Elvis
Chocolate Mint
2x Triple Chocolate Brownie
2x Molten Chocolate

$165.00
$165.00
Refreshing Delights 12-Pack

Refreshing Delights 12-Pack

A refreshing burst of flavor and fruit in every pie

Key Lime
Caramel Apple
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Mint
Chocolate Strawberry
Banana Cream
Coconut Cream
Chocolate Raspberry
Creamsicle
Peaches N' Cream
Cherry Vanilla
Lemon Cream

$165.00
$165.00

Build your own packs

GET YOUR PEACE OF THE PIE!

Build Your Own 12-Pack

Build Your Own 12-Pack

A dozen pies of your choice

Go crazy: order a dozen Key Limes!

$175.00
$175.00
Build Your Own 6-Pack

Build Your Own 6-Pack

A half-dozen choices to make

Here's where you can order that week's supply of coffee toffee you've been craving.

$90.00
$90.00
Build-A-Pack (24 Pies)

Build Your Own 24-Pack

Get a Double Dozen of your favorites

Twenty Coconut Creams, three mints, and a strawberry? No Problem!

$225.00
$225.00

Half Dozen Options

Just a mouthful of sugar...

Fresh as Fruit 6-Pack

Fresh as Fruit 6-Pack

A fruity refresher course

Key Lime
Strawberry Shortcake
Chocolate Mint
Coconut Cream
The Elvis
Triple Vanilla

$90.00
$90.00
Classic Pies 6-Pack

Classic Pies 6-Pack

The Original Pie Flavors

Pecan Pie
Caramel Apple
Boston Cream
Key Lime
Coconut Cream
Banana Cream

$90.00
$90.00
Chocolate Lover's 6-Pack

Chocolate Lover's 6-Pack

Experience pure chocolate bliss

Triple Chocolate Brownie
Cookie Dough
Candy Bar
The Elvis
Molten Chocolate
Caramel Brownie

$90.00
$90.00
Caramel Delights 6-Pack

Caramel Delights 6-Pack

Featuring our house-made creamy and delicious Caramel

Caramel Brownie
Caramel Apple
Caramel Coffee Toffee
Candy Bar
Peanut Butter Brownie
Cinnamon Bun

$90.00
$90.00

Our Locations

Visit our family-owned shops

Serving New Jersey & Florida year-round

326 Carpenters Lane

Cape May, NJ

609-435-5321
Open
SUNDAY-THURSDAY: 11-10PM
FRIDAY & SATURDAY: 11-11PM
Third Party Delivery, Catering, and Pre-Order Customer Pickup Available

7307 Ventnor Ave

Ventnor City, NJ

609-457-0655
OPEN
MONDAY-WEDNESDAY: 12-6PM
THURSDAY: 12-9PM
FRIDAY & SATURDAY: 12-10PM
SUNDAY: 12-8PM
Third Party Delivery, Catering, and Pre-Ordering Available

8 AVILES STREET

SAINT AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

904-295-8232
OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK: 10AM-10PM
Third Party Delivery, Catering, and Pre-Order Customer Pickup Available
TASTING TOURS & PRIVATE EVENTS OFFERED!