THE PERFECT ADDITION TO YOUR FREEZER! PACKAGES ARE SOLD IN QUANTITIES OF 6, 12, AND 24 PIES.

THE PEACE PIE EXPERIENCE DIRECT SHIPPING

12-pack of peace pies

Peace Pie Classics

The Peace Pies That Started It All! Our First and Still some of the most popular Fan Favorites To This Day!
Classics Package Includes one of each Flavor:
Caramel Brownie.  Pecan Pie. 
Cookies N' Cream.
Strawberry Shortcake.  Banana Cream.  Coconut Cream.
Boston Cream.  Key Lime Pie.  Caramel Apple.
Molten Chocolate.  Peanut Butter Cup.  Chocolate Mint.

$165.00
$165.00
Refreshing Delights

Refreshing Delights

This 12 pack is a refreshing burst of flavor in every pie. Enjoy your Daily Serving of Fruit the Peace Pie Way!


Refreshing Delights Contains These Flavors

Key Lime Pie. Caramel Apple. Strawberry Shortcake. Chocolate Mint.
Chocolate Strawberry. Banana Cream. Coconut Cream. Chocolate Raspberry.
Creamsicle.  Peaches 'N' Cream.  Cherry Vanilla.  Lemon Cream.

$165.00
$165.00
Chocolate Obsession Collection

Chocolate Obsession Collection

Chocolate, chocolate, chocolate!  This irresistible assortment gives you chocolate every way you love it: rich, cocoa mousse, fudge brownies, chocolate chips and more layers over ice cream, sandwiched between chocolate shortbread  cookies. The ultimate treats to satisfy your sweet tooth. 

Caramel Brownie
Cookie Dough
The Elvis
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate Covered Strawberry
S'mores
Candy Bar
Chocolate Mint
2x Triple Chocolate Brownie
2x Molten Chocolate

$165.00
$165.00
Caramel Delights

Caramel Delights

Featuring our House-Made Creamy and Delicious Caramel over even more homemade layers and toppings!
Caramel Brownie.  Caramel Apple.
Caramel Coffee Toffee.  Candy Bar.  Peanut Butter Brownie.  Cinnamon Bun.

$90.00
$90.00
CLASSIC SIX PACK OF PIE FLAVORS

CLASSIC SIX PACK OF PIE FLAVORS

PEACE PIE'S COLLECTION OF FLAVORS 
TOPPED WITH A CHILL VERSION OF YOUR FAVORITE BAKED ALL-AMERICAN PIES
Includes one each of our Original Pie Flavors! 
Pecan Pie,  Caramel Apple, Boston Cream, Key Lime,
Coconut Cream, Banana Cream

$90.00
$90.00
Fresh as Fruit Dessert 6-Pack

Fresh as Fruit Dessert 6-Pack

This Refreshing Six Pack includes the flavors

Key Lime.  Strawberry Shortcake.  Chocolate Mint.  Coconut Cream.  

The Elvis. Triple Vanilla.

$90.00
$90.00
Chocolate Lover's Six Pack

Chocolate Lover's Six Pack

Experience pure chocolate bliss with our Chocolate Lover's Pack at Peace Pie. This delightful 6-pack features Triple Chocolate Brownie, Cookie Dough, Candy Bar, The Elvis, Molten Chocolate, and Salted Caramel Brownie. A dream come true for chocolate aficionados!
Our Chocolate Lovers Pack includes One each of these Flavors
Triple Chocolate Brownie
Cookie Dough
Candy Bar
The Elvis
Molten Chocolate
Caramel Brownie

$90.00
$90.00
Caramel Heaven Pack

Caramel Heaven Pack

You will fall in love with our velvety house-made caramel with this collection of our all time best selling ice cream sandwiches. Creamy smooth caramel is drizzled over a variety of toppings and ice creams, complimented by the signature crunch of our shortbread cookies.

3x Salted Caramel Brownie
3x Caramel Coffee Toffee
3x Candy Bar
3x Salted Caramel Apple

$165.00
$165.00

GET YOUR PEACE OF THE PIE!

CUSTOMIZE YOUR SELECTION!

Available in half and full dozen packages

BUILD A CUSTOM SIX PACK

BUILD A CUSTOM SIX PACK

THE SIX PACK

Build Your Custom Six Pack here!

Also Available at Discounted Rates as 12 and 24 Packs

$89.00
$89.00
Build-A-Pack (12 Pies)

Build-A-Pack (12 Pies)

THE 12 PACK OF PEACE PIES

Build Your Custom Twelve Pack here!

Note: (Not visible on storefront)

  1. Do not change/remove the product options. Otherwise, new variants cannot be generated
  2. Do not remove duplicated products manually. Otherwise, you may corrupt the bundle
  3. Deleting or turning this bundle product to draft will stop the bundle from working.
  4. Each variant is a bundle built by a customer, this means that deleting variants will prevent that customer from checking out

$175.00
$175.00

SHOP LOCATIONS

VISIT OUR FAMILY OWNED AND OPERATED STORES IN NEW JERSEY & FLORIDA

OPEN YEAR ROUND

8 AVILES STREET

SAINT AUGUSTINE, FLORIDA

EST. 2017

904.295.8232

SHOP HOURS:

OPEN 7 DAYS A WEEK: 10AM-10PM

THIRD PARTY DELIVERY AVAILABLE

CATERING SERVICES OFFERED

CUSTOMER PRE-ORDER FOR PICK UP

TASTING TOURS & PRIVATE EVENTS OFFERED!