Peace Pie Experience

Order Options to Suit Your Needs:
Pickup, Delivery, & Shipping

ice cream sandwiches
Pick a store, and we'll have your order waiting for you.
Offering Same-Day Delivery through our Restaurant Delivery Partners
Not close to a store? No problem. We'll ship it to you via Next-Day Ground.

Call to action


Curbside Pickup and Takeout Window service is available at all locations, including St. Augustine, FL, Charleston, SC, Ventnor, NJ, and Cape May, NJ. By clicking the button below, you can choose your store, pick your Peace Pies, pay online, and schedule your order for a date/time or ASAP.

You can also place an order at the shop or call in pickup order as well by calling one of our stores.

Call to action


We're offering Same-Day Delivery with our restaurant delivery partners.

Partners include Grubhub, DoorDash, Uber Eats, Bite Squad, and EZ Cater. Click to see which options are available in your location.

Call to action


Not close enough to order pickup or delivery? No problem. We ship our Peace Pies directly to you, maintaining the utmost quality and freshness by shipping in dry ice.

What if my state is not included for Shipping?

Give us a call, and we will see what we can do to ship Peace Pies directly to your home.

Can I get delivery without using a third-party partner?

We are happy to accommodate your special delivery needs! Call the store closest to you, and we will work with you personally for delivery and large order options. 

Can I schedule a pickup order for a future date/time?

Absolutely! When you order pickup online, you can choose ASAP (Instant Pickup) or Schedule (pick a day/time). 

When I order online, I don't see all the flavors i remember seeing in the store. Can i still get those flavors?

We love creating new flavors at Peace Pie. With a wide span of geographies, each location creates its own distinct flavors with the ingredients and traditions local to them. We have 20 unique flavors available for shipping, delivery, and pickup at all times, in all locations. To see what other flavors your store has -- and to add them to your order -- just give us a call or leave us a note. 

If you have an idea for a flavor, let us know!

When I do a "Build Your Own" Shipping Order, I get an error when I have "#" of Pies in my cart. What's Happening?

Keeping our Peace Pies fresh and tasty is of utmost importance to us, and is essential to your Peace Pie Experience. To do that, we size, weigh, and test our Peace Pie shipping packages in advance to make sure you get the product you expect. Then, we ship our Peace Pies in dry ice, in specially sized boxes. These boxes have strict amounts of Peace Pies they can fit, and hence our unit selection of 6, 12, and 24 at a time.

Order Size Examples: 

  • - 12 Pies, but not 10 or 15
  • - 24 Pies, but not 19 or 28
  • - 36 Pies, but not 31 or 41
  • - 48 Pies, but not 41 or 50

Close (esc)

The American Six Pack

Celebrate Labor Day with American Flavor.

Feast on Cherry Pie, Blueberry Cobbler, S'mores, & More!

Order Now

Age verification

By clicking enter you are verifying that you are old enough to consume alcohol.


Shopping Cart

Your cart is currently empty.
Shop now